I decided to stop at 30 songs on my Mississippi demo real. That means I made 30 demos in 30 days. It’s been good for production and recording experience, but I also want to do some more traditional songwriting using the guitar.
Mississippi is an experiment in pop music. I’ve mentioned in previous posts that I’ve been plagued by being a “pop” songwriter since the start. It seems no matter how hard I try to keep the pop influence out of what I do, it leaks in. The Mississippi project was a blatant acceptance of that pesky pop curse/blessing.
But I’ve had enough for now. I want to work on something different for a while. I’m not sure what yet. Maybe, I’ll go back to my initial plan for 2024 and write some songs using the electric guitar, or using the slide on the old Gibson acoustic. I was still practicing guitar throughout the entire Mississippi sessions even though the recordings don’t have any guitar.
Or perhaps, I’ll work on putting together a chap book of poetry. Or maybe I should return to the Cult Boy project.
Then again, I might re-record the best songs from Mississippi. I could move from using GarageBand to Logic Pro and force myself to learn better production techniques. I could tone down the “pop” a little, add guitar, and really work on getting stronger vocals and mixes.
Or maybe I’ll go back and record the best of 2023’s 60 songs that I wrote on the ukulele. I think there are some good ones in that batch.
The Mississippi demos are good but could be better.
I’m happy with what I recorded, but it could be better. Working with nothing but an iPad and GarageBand, including only using the internal iPad mic for vocals, it’s not bad. But I still have a lot to learn.
The vocals were my biggest challenge and the thing I think I could improve the most. A better mic would help. But I also live in a condominium and feel uncomfortable singing at full volume. The vocals are all done at low-volume levels. I may have added too much reverb and delay to the vocals for the first 15-18 songs. Then I backed off a little on vocal effects on the second half. I also did less harmonies.
Musically, I made a lot of spontaneous choices. Some of the drum tracks were programmed quickly, and some were even just a click of the “random” button in GarageBand. Some of the bass and synth work is simply automated arpeggios. I’m mostly happy with how the music came out. It’s good enough for demos. But I’d like some real instruments in there, including guitar on some tracks.
The songs themselves could also be improved. I could rework some lyrics. Some of the songs might even work better to completely different music. That’s the glory of songwriting. You can always change the work as you go through the process. Leonard Cohen was known for creating multiple versions of the same song.
For the moment, I’m not sure what the next project will be. I’ll just take a short time to reflect and decompress and go from there. I’ll let you know. – dse
My simple and opinionated answer is “No.” There. You can stop reading now, or if you want to understand a little more about my conclusions concerning songwriting camps and classes, continue.
I’ve attended several writing and music courses, seminars, camps, etc., in my lifetime. Most recently, in 2023, I went to Rodney Crowell’s songwriting camp, and I took Rachael Cerrotti’s memoir writing class. Honestly, the much less expensive of the two, Rachael’s class, had more benefits to me as a writer. I learned more. But was it enough to make me feel like it really helped me greatly as a writer? Probably not.
It all depends on your experience and desire.
The answer to the question about whether or not songwriting and writing camps and classes are worth the cost really depends on two things.
Your experience level. While it’s true that we can always learn, if I spend hundreds or thousands of dollars to discover that the teachers are no more advanced than me as a writer, I may have wasted my money.
Your desire. I don’t regret any class or camp I’ve attended. I even knew going into them that I might not get what I wanted out of them. But I had the desire to attend and mingle with like-minded people. And it was fun.
If you are a beginning writer or musician and you want to improve, then yes, by all means, take classes and go to camps. If you’ve been writing for most of a lifetime and have already written or published a variety of works in any format, then think twice. Here’s why.
You don’t get enough for your money.
If you are loaded and don’t care about costs, this does not apply. If you just want the experience, and/or want to be a super-fan of the individual(s) offering the class or the camp, again, do it. It can be fun and rewarding.
But if, assuming you’re already a fairly decent writer, you expect to get in-depth training that will make you a better writer, and perhaps lead you closer to a successful writing career, save your money. I’ve outlined a few reasons why.
You won’t get much personal attention. My experience in writing classes and camps is that there are too many students for the teachers to truly reach on a personal level. I’m a teacher. I know that it’s impossible to mentor 100 students individually. However, I will work in-depth with individual students if they ask me to during the duration of a course, and even after the course in some cases. This kind of in-depth help does not happen at commercial songwriting camps and classes. You are one of many, and the “teachers” are often only teachers because they are successful in the business and have “names.” Most are not really “teachers.”
You are mostly taught broad overviews. Sure, I might pick up some tidbits of helpful information at writing camps and classes. I might get a healthy dose of inspiration. I’ve heard some great stories. But as a self-trained and motivated songwriter and writer, I’ve done a lot of study. I’ve put in years of practice. I’d say that 95% or more of the information I was taught at the courses and camps I’ve attended included information I already understood.
You can learn this stuff for free. Even before the Internet, anyone had the ability to become a great writer or songwriter. You just have to read and listen. Dig deep. I was studying Bob Dylan and Robert Johnson in my 20s. I’ve spent countless hours reading biographies and how-to books from libraries at no cost to me.
Hard work is what makes you better. Courses can be helpful. But if you want to write better songs, write songs. If you want to become a better poet, write poetry. Pretty simple.
If I were friends with Tom Waits.
It might sound like I think I’m pretty damn good at what I do. Well, yes, I do think I’ve learned a lot over my years of practice and experience. Does that mean I’m beyond learning? Fuck no! I understand less than ever.
But if I pay $1000 and only learn a couple of tidbits of information that may not really make much of a difference in what I do, was that cost effective. Nope. And if you think I’ll pay $10,000 for one-on-one time with some self-proclaimed writing guru/coach, you’re crazy.
If I were friends with say, Tom Waits, Bob Dylan, or Steve Earle, then maybe I could really get some benefit from a teacher/mentor relationship. I mean that’s really the best way of learning, to be in an active and ongoing relationship with someone who has more experience than you do at the craft. That, unfortunately is not realistic or an easy situation to find oneself in.
In the camps and classes, my experience with songwriters like Rodney Crowell, Joe Henry, and others was this: To the lesser experienced writers, they had much more to teach. With the more experienced writers, they basically looked at us and said, “That’s a good song.” That was my $2500 lesson.
If you really want to become a professional songwriter, perhaps a full-length course, or even a program at a college that specializes in music and the music business would be a better route.
The business of being undiscovered.
Recently, I posted a comment on a “songwriting” course being advertised on Facebook. I said that with my experience, “I should be teaching the class, not taking it.” You might imagine that I got some feedback, both supportive and questioning. But it’s true. I’ve likely studied the craft as much, and written as many songs, as anyone who teaches songwriting. Add the fact that I’m actually educated as a teacher and I think I have a fair argument. The difference is simply that I’ve not worked my way into “the business of songwriting.”
So then maybe I should take a class? It’s also my experience, that these short courses on writing and songwriting don’t really give us much new information on how to succeed in the business. So it becomes a catch 22. I even attended a music business conference in Indianapolis, Indiana back in 2003 or 2004. It didn’t really equip me with anything I hadn’t already learned in books I’d read. Getting into the business is hard work, but often a very large element of chance or luck is also involved.
I’m “undiscovered.” And becoming discovered takes even more work and energy. After trying to get discovered for a few years, I chose college and a family. Then I had bills to pay and responsibilities to attend to. I couldn’t just pick up stakes at a whim and spend all my time in a major music or writing city knocking on doors and attempting to be “discovered.” It’s not that simple.
But back to the question at hand. Are songwriting and writing courses and camps worth the cost. From my perspective, they are not. But if you want to have some fun and mingle with famous people and other writers, do it. Maybe, I’ll run into you. – dse
At the time of this writing, my demo reel, Mississippi (and other demos) has a total of 20 tracks. And I’m not stopping yet. Check it out on the Bandcamp player below:
This demo process has been great practice. My original goal for 2024 was to write music using the electric guitar. But it’s harder for me to record guitar with my current setup. Every track you hear on Mississippi was completed using sampled instruments on GarageBand with an iPad. I even used the built-in iPad microphones for the vocals.
Here’s the current track list:
Mississippi
Tame the Beast
I Need a Camera
Give Me Back My Angel
Farmington
Play Hard
People Are in Love
Break the Chain
Chasing Ghosts
Flex
Madawaska Sky
No Party
Glory, Glory
Brittle
Lean Into It
Cold
Don’t Let Me Down Easy
Waiting for the Thaw
She Ruined Me
Shit City
Writing songs using a DAW works much differently than writing on a live instrument. Traditionally, whether I write the lyrics first or with the music, I sit down and work out the song in real time by playing and singing at the same time.
But with electronic music, I program the music first. I have a ton of lyrics already written, so I may or may not program a piece with a lyric in mind, but more often not. Most of the music for these songs was programmed before choosing which lyric would be used.
There is a sense of chance, experimentation, and randomness in this method. Each composition is like a puzzle that I need to put together. I have to make a lyric fit to a specific piece of music. Sometimes, I might tweak one or the other a little to make it work, but not too much. I’ve even closed my eyes and opened up lyrics to go with music for a few of these songs.
Contemplating Style and content.
My songwriting style can differ greatly depending on the writing process I choose, and what instrument(s) is acting as my accompaniment. I’ll be the first to point out that I’m not being consistent in a given style here.
If you listen to the entire demo reel, you’ll hear music influences ranging from dance to new wave to synth wave to punk. You’ll also hear softer singer-songwriter pieces. In the end, it’s all pop. Instead of fighting the pop creep that always seems to find its way into my music, I decided to embrace it.
In the future, I may choose to focus on one of the styles you hear on the reel and release an album. But for now, it’s a demo, and demos are meant to show the variety of styles a songwriter can create.
I tend to avoid comparing my work to other (more popular) artists. I think it behooves us as artists to abandon emulation. We can’t avoid some similarities to other artists, but the less we try to emulate or compare ourselves to others, the more original our own work becomes. You might think it’s a compliment to say my work sounds like a Frank Sinatra or Metallica, but it’s actually something I want to avoid.
Still struggling with vocals and mixes.
Although I’m improving, I’m still struggling with vocals and mixes.
First, I haven’t been singing much lately. So my voice is pretty rough. I struggle with intonation and my range is limited. I’ve been focusing more on the deeper end of my voice, but that has its own set of challenges. Second, I’m using an iPad microphone.
As for mixes, GarageBand is not suited to do great mixing and I still have a lot to learn about audio frequencies and proper mixing techniques.
This project is also moving me toward switching to Logic Pro. I’ve had Logic Pro on my iPad for almost a year. I occasionally open it up and fiddle around. But while working on Mississippi (and other demos), I decided to learn how to program beats using Logic Pro. I have half or more of these songs’ drum tracks programmed using Logic Pro. That’s a start in getting familiar with the DAW. I did have some issues with glitching however.
That’s it for now. I’ll likely keep adding songs to the Mississippi demo reel until I reach a couple dozen or more. Keep checking back for new material. – dse
Songwriting has been compared to a lot of different things. But the truth is that songwriting is not some kind of magical process. It’s work. It’s hard work. And for the greatest songwriters, a lifetime of hard work.
I’ve often heard songwriters talk about how songs just materialize out of thin air. Some suggest that there is some kind of higher power planting the ideas in their heads and that they are simply conduits or recipients. I call bullshit.
Don’t get me wrong. I believe there is a sense of mysticism in all of the arts. I believe there is a spirit, or muse if you will, that might turn the faucet of ideas on and off. But in the end, I think songwriting is hard work. It’s not magical. Songwriting is more like designing and building something architectural.
It’s taken me a lot of years to come to this conclusion.
I’ve been writing songs since I was seven years old. I’ve written more than 1200 songs in my lifetime and a few hundred other pieces of music. There might have been a time when I’d have claimed that there was some kind of magic involved in the process. But let’s consider how a song comes to someone, and the steps it takes to completion.
The idea: Every song has to start with an idea. Where do the ideas come from? Just about anywhere. You might get an idea from a life event, a movie, or even another song. But every idea, in reality, is coming from your conscious or subconscious mind. Those ideas are directly related to everything you do. Your experiences, in essence, build your character, and in turn, your ideas for songs.
The design: Once you have an idea, just as with a building, you must start to design your song. This might include basic themes, rhyme schemes, musical styles, and rhythms. Sometimes, you zip right through this process. Other times it’s more thought out. In either case, it’s not really magic. You have to work.
The foundation: I would argue that there are three parts to the foundation of a good song. First, the story/lyric. Second, the musical treatment. Third, the hook. Again, these things don’t come to you out of thin air. You have to work at them to develop what works well. Sometimes, that is an almost instantaneous process. Other times, there is more development involved.
The structure: This is where it all comes together. I’ve written songs in many different ways. I’ve written words and music at the same time. I’ve written music first and then shaped words around that music. And I’ve written words first and then built the music to fit around the words. I’ve also built songs using digital audio workshops. Without structure, you really don’t have a song. You might, however, have an ambient composition, a poem, or spoken word.
Here’s where the magic really happens.
But Dan, you said there is no magic. I lied. There is.
The magic to creating great songs, or any kind of great artwork for that matter, lies in one’s ability to be an alchemist.
Meriam Webster defines alchemy as:
the medieval chemical science and speculative philosophy whose aims were the transmutation of the base metals into gold, the discovery of a universal cure for diseases, and the discovery of a means of indefinitely prolonging life.
Alchemy requires experimentation. Great songs come from experimentation. Try this note, or that instrument. Use a minor scale here but a major scale there. Mix two instruments or genres that are not often combined. This is where the magic happens. And that takes work.
So from the very start it’s all about building something. Some songs might just be a tent or a fence. Others might be houses, churches, or grand theaters. But a song is built.
The process may be fast. Someone like Joe Henry would say he lets the song come to him. That might be a fast process. On the other hand, Leonard Cohen was known to write dozens of verses to get the best ones. Is there a right way or a wrong way. Not really.
But I find this idea that songs and music magically form through us from a higher power to be either superstitious or pretentious. It’s not magic. There is work involved.
My entire life has been a platform for song ideas. My conscious and subconscious mind develop those ideas. Then I work hard to build and shape each song. And sometimes, I tear them down and start over. That’s songwriting. – dse